For over a decade, the International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network (IJAN) has distorted the term "Zionist" to promote anti-Israel rhetoric. In 2015, IJAN published “IJAN Stands with NYC Students for Justice in Palestine,” calling Zionism, “a racist ideology of Jewish supremacy.” Almost a decade later, IJAN published, “Standing for Palestinian lives, land, and liberation is not antisemitic. It’s part of the fight against racism,” claiming “One cannot be truly anti-racist without being anti-Zionist.”
In fact, these truths are self-evident:
- Zionism is about creating a Jewish democratic state not opposing Arabs or Muslims: Zionism does not preclude Arabs and Muslims from the Jewish State – in the 2026 election, Arab parties won 19 of 120 seats in Israel’s parliament, the Knesset. Nevertheless, in 2011, IJAN published an article claiming that Zionism is a “program against Arabs and Muslims.”
Historian Walter Laqueur's book, History of Zionism, explains that religious coexistence was central to Herzl’s view of Zionism. In “The Jewish State,” Theodor Herzl writes, “Everyone will be as free and undisturbed in their faith or their disbelief as they are in their nationality.” Modern Zionism spawned a diverse society in which Jews and Arabs live together in Israel. According to the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, 22% of Israel's population identifies as Arab – and approximately twenty percent of Israel’s university students, doctors, and nurses are Arab. Israel's Declaration of Independence (1948) offers “complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex” and “full and equal citizenship and due representation in all its provisional and permanent institutions.”
- Zionism is not racist: IJAN frequently refers to Zionism as “a racist ideology.” Yet there are dark-skinned Israelis and light-skinned Palestinians – they are in a national conflict not a racial one. Injecting charges of “racism” is simply an attempt to slur Zionism and Jews. The Middle East historian Efraim Karsh explains that “Zionism, historically speaking, has in fact shown little interest in race as a factor in shaping the character and ethos of Israeli society.”
President and Chief Operating Officer of Jewish Future Promise, Hadara Ishak states, “Zionism is a principle of national self-determination that the world affirms for every other people on earth.” She highlights the hypocrisy in referring to Jewish self-determination (Zionism) as racism, stating, “No one calls Irish nationalism ‘racism.’ No one calls the Palestinian national movement ‘racism.’ The unique standard is applied to Jewish nationhood, and only to Jewish nationhood.”
Ishak’s statement highlights the reality that many other nations enjoy a religious and cultural identity without being characterized as racist. The Pew Research Center reports that 22% of countries have an official state religion and another 20% have a preferred religion, yet only the democratic Jewish state is the one considered racist.
- Anti-Zionism is a Mask for Antisemitism: Historian Gil Troy’s “The Essential Guide to Zionism, Anti-Zionism, Antisemitism and Jew-Hatred” argues that anti-Zionists use “Jew” and “Zionist” synonymously to further hide their antisemitism as legitimate opposition to Israel. It’s not Jews who confuse anti-Zionism with antisemitism, it’s the anti-Zionists: they have been targeting Jews, and tapping into the historic swamp of Jew-hating slurs for decades.
Troy explains, “demonizing Israel has helped paint a portrait of Jews as ‘a shameful people, a satanic people, this abominable people, universally loathed.” Troy brings forth a quote from Bayard Rustin, an organizer of Martin Luther King’s March on Washington, who said, “When people criticize Zionists, they mean Jews; you are talking antisemitism.״ Troy uses the example of Mohamed Sabry Soliman, who on June 1, 2025, threw a Molotov cocktail at pro-Israel demonstrators in Colorado. Troy explains, “His crime murdered one 82-year-old woman. When interviewed by authorities, Soliman said he wanted to kill all Zionist people, blurring Zionists and Jews and pro-Israeli protesters together.”
- Zionism and White Supremacy: In “White Jews: An Intersectional Approach,” Professor David Schraub explains that, “tropes of Jewish Whiteness are quite implicated in how Israel is talked about outside of Israel.” Schraub believes that the trope of Jewish whiteness, particularly white supremacy in Zionism, “seems to step forward and subsume Jewish identity entirely: Jewishness is only recognizable as an empowered, even hyperpowered, status.” Schraub argues that the trope that Zionism is white supremacy is used to colour Israel as a further extension of European colonialism. Schraub notes slapping the label of “white supremacy” on Zionism does not reflect the lived Jewish experience. For instance, he explains, “White supremacists, of course, deny Jews are White.” Furthermore, the majority of Israel's population is not white, with the majority descending from the Middle East, North Africa, Iran, and Ethiopia. Note: white racists who celebrate whiteness – say Jews aren’t white; anti-racists who disrespect whiteness – say Jews are!
- Zionism Is Not Colonialism: In 2015, IJAN inducted into its charter the statement, “Zionism—the founding and current ideology that manifested in the State of Israel—took root in the era of European colonialism.” Despite this, leading UCLA political scientist Dov Waxman asserts that “Zionist settlers were not European colonialists.” Gil Troy elaborates on this statement, arguing that “Zionism, meaning Jewish nationalism, is anomalous. It’s a story of powerlessness not imperialism, genuine indigeneity not colonialism.” Troy asserts, “The Land of Israel, Jews’ ancestral homeland, was the logical, legitimate, and viable place to relaunch that Jewish national project.” He argues that Jews were returning home, “to build and be rebuilt, not extract and exploit.” He dispels the narrative that Jews were sent to Israel, “from ‘home’ to enrich back home” because “they were coming home.”